The Biggest Meldowns in Sports History
With the high-stakes play of competition, it’s no wonder that some athletes, coaches, and fans crack under pressure. Whether it’s in response to off-field anxieties or disappointing game results, sporting-related outbursts can have major negative consequences for all involved. In this guide to the biggest meltdowns in sports history, we’ve looked at some memorable moments of players, coaches, and fans behaving badly. While they may be controversial, these events continue to have an impact on pop culture today.
What Are the Biggest Sports Outbursts?
To get this guide started, we’ve defined what a sports meltdown is in the context of this guide and have discussed why and how they come to be. We’ve then begun our list of the biggest outbursts in sports history, beginning with John McEnroe’s iconic meltdown at Wimbledon 1981.
Other events include Ron Artest’s “Malice at the Palace” brawl, Serena Williams’ much-publicized outbursts, and Mike Tyson’s infamous ear-biting incident. Whether you’re a sports fan or not, there’s a good chance you’re familiar with most of these meltdowns.
- What is a Sports Meltdown?
- 1. John McEnroe – Wimbledon 1981
- 2. Zinedine Zidane’s Headbutt 2006
- 3. Serena Williams’ Outbursts 2009 & 2018
- 4. Ron Artest’s Brawl 2004
- 5. Bobby Knight’s Chair-Throwing 1985
- 6. Juan Marichal’s Bat Attack 1965
- 7. Vancouver’s Stanley Cup Riot 2011
- 8. Tonya Harding’s Sabotage 1994
- 9. Mike Tyson’s Ear-Biting 1997
What Classifies as a Sports Meltdown?
Although some pundits may define a sports meltdown as an unexpected crashing of team or player performance, this article is concerned with the often violent or abusive outburts by athletes, coaches, and fans. Often, these are heavily criticized for going against sporting values of fairness, respect, and humility, and in many cases, result in harsh penalties.
It’s not hard to see how these incidents happen. Professional athletes have dedicated their whole lives to their sports with passion and sacrifice, so when things don’t go their way, tensions can be high. In some cases, the bad behaviours are result of the immense pressures of success or fame, which boil to a point they explode. The following are examples of both instances.
1. John McEnroe’s Wimbledon Meltdown 1981
While US tennis star John McEnroe was always known for his short temper, his most iconic meltdown came during the 1981 Wimbledon Championships. After the umpire called his shot out in a first-round match against Tom Gulikson, McEnroe famously shouted, “You cannot be serious!” He received a $1,500 fine for then calling him “the pits of the world.”
Throughout the match, he also swore at the tournament referee, smashed his racket, and sarcastically clapped the crowd. His behaviour stood out against Wimbledon’s respectable reputation, and he quickly became controversial for his rage. Nevertheless, despite almost being ejected for his performance, McEnroe later won the tournament.
2. Zinedine Zidane’s World Cup Outburst 2006
In one of the most shocking sports outbursts in soccer history, France’s Zinedine Zidane drew swift condemnation for his headbutting of Italy’s Marco Materazzi during extra time of the 2006 FIFA World Cup Final. While unknown at the time, the headbutt to Materazzi’s chest came after the Italian insulted Zidane’s sister.
Tragically, this was to be the final professional game of the French captain, and France later went on to lose the final on penalties. The moment had a huge impact on Zidane’s legacy, and while he still won the tournament’s Golden Ball, the violent act was initially condemned for being at odds with the World Cup’s values.
3. Serena Williams’ US Open Outbursts in 2009 & 2018
As well as being women’s tennis’ greatest ever player, Serena Williams also holds the honor of having two of the biggest meltdowns in sports history. The first came at the US Open semifinal in 2009 after she was called for a foot fault. This resulted in her threatening the lineswoman, which was penalized with a point penalty that ended the match.
In the 2018 final against Naomi Osaka, Williams again exploded after being penalized for coaching. In response, she smashed her racket and called the umpire a “liar” and a “thief”. There was a fierce backlash from the crowd, sparking debates about officiating bias in tennis. It also caused chaos at the best tennis sportsbooks, with Osaka’s win a surprise for all.
4. Ron Artest’s “Malice at the Palace” Brawl 2004
A truly crazy moment in sports history unfolded in November 2004, when an NBA game between the Indiana Pacers and Detroit Pistons unraveled into chaos, now remembered as the “Malice at the Palace”. The incident started when a fan threw a cup of soda at Pacers forward Ron Artest while he was resting during an already tense game.
Artest responded by entering the crowd and throwing punches, which sparked a brawl involving fans, security, and Pacers teammates Stephen Jackson and Jermaine O’Neal. Nine players were suspended for a total of 146 games in the aftermath, and significant damage was done to the NBA’s reputation. As a result, the NBA heightened security protocols and enhanced player conduct rules.
5. Bobby Knight’s College Football Chair-Throwing 1985
It’s not just the major leagues that have seen out-of-control outbursts. In 1985, the coach of the college football team, the Indiana Hoosiers, reacted with rage against the referees during a game against Purdue. Believing the officials were making biased foul calls, Knight screamed at the referees before throwing a plastic chair across the court.
The crowd was instantly stunned by the action, and Knight was immediately ejected and suspended for one game. The NCAA then tightened its rules on sideline behaviour. Although three-time NCAA champion Knight was already infamous for his outbursts, the chair-throwing incident brought him to national attention that endures today.
6. Juan Marichal’s Bat Attack 1965
One of the most violent sports outbursts in Major League Baseball’s history, the Juan Marichal incident of 1965 was a major controversy at the time. The meltdown came during a game between long-term rivals, the San Francisco Giants and Los Angeles Dodgers, with the Giants’ pitcher set to bat against Sandy Koufax.
After several aggressive pitches and verbal arguments, Dodgers catcher John Roseboro returned the ball to the mound close to Marichal’s head. Marichal then turned and smacked Roseboro on the head with his bat twice, triggering an on-field brawl. While Roseboro later required stitches, Marichal was suspended and handed a $1,750 fine.
7. Vancouver’s Stanley Cup Riot 2011
One of the biggest meltdowns in sports history wasn’t initiated by coaches or players but rather disappointed fans. After the Vancouver Canucks lost Game 7 of the 2011 Stanley Cup Final to the Boston Bruins, downtown Vancouver quickly exploded into a riot. Thousands of angry fans flipped and torched cars, looted stores, and shattered windows.
The riot resulted in 140 injured people and over $5 million in damages. With footage from the chaos broadcast around the world, Vancouver was embarrassed on the global stage. The event drew comparisons to the 1955 Richard Riot in Montreal, another unrest led by NHL fans, proving just how seriously Canadians take their hockey.
8. Tonya Harding’s Sabotage 1994
If a sports meltdown is immortalized into an Oscar-winning film, it’s clear just how consequential it was. In the lead-up to the 1994 Winter Olympics, American figure skaters Tonya Harding and Nancy Kerrigan were considered to be strong contenders. However, Kerrigan’s chances came crashing down when she was struck in the knee with a baton by a man hired by Harding’s ex-husband.
Although Harding wasn’t directly linked to the attack, she did admit to knowing about it and attempting to cover up the crime. Kerrigan recovered and went on to win silver at the Olympics and first at the 1993 US National Figure Skating Championship, while Harding was handed a life ban from figure skating for the jealousy-fueled conspiracy.
9. Mike Tyson’s Bites Evander Holyfield’s Ear 1997
Before 1997, Mike Tyson was already considered to be one of the most controversial figures in boxing. Having been released from jail in 1995, Tyson was scheduled to face Evander Holyfield in a highly anticipated rematch. Frustrated with Holyfied’s strategy in the ring, Tyson lost his cool in the third round.
He bit his opponent’s right ear, receiving a two-point deduction, then followed it with another bite on the left ear moments later. His infraction saw Tyson disqualified and chaos erupt in Holyfield’s corner. The incident resulted in the loss of Tyson’s boxing license and severely damaged his reputation, with critics shaming his dirty tactics.